Tuesday, June 8, 2021

The Names of D&D

 A self-admitted frustrated grognard posted on MeWe today that he was unsatisfied with the label "Original D&D" for the early brown and white box editions. He was partly making fun of himself and partly grasping for a better term, as a fan of the original. It set me on a track of thinking that resulted in this:

All editions and variations of D&D are "D&D" - that is the collective. When making a clarification, we should use 

  • '74 D&D (three books)
  • '76 D&D (seven books, for all practical purposes this is just an earlier, messier version of AD&D)
  • Basic D&D (further clarified as Holmes, BX, or BECMI)
  • Advanced D&D (further clarified as 1e or 2e)
  • Modern D&D (further clarified as an edition 3.5, 4th, 5th)

Here was my train of thought.

[In response to the root post.] Everything else has a name. Basic D&D (Holmes, BX, BECMI), Advanced D&D (1e or 2e), or a modern edition (3.5, 4, 5). I'd say that Oe should just be called "D&D", but that's not realistic. All Corvettes are Corvettes. But then we add a year when we want to talk about a specific model (and sometimes other labels, like Stingray). So I guess this version has to have a label. I've seen Original D&D, Three Little (Brown) Books (TLB or TLBB), Whitebox, etc. I kind of like 1974 D&D, but even then there are distinctions. Three-book 1974 D&D is quite different from seven-book 1976 D&D. I guess maybe that's the answer for me: '74 D&D, '76 D&D, Basic (Holmes, BX, BECMI), Advanced D&D (1e or 2e), or a modern edition (3.5, 4, 5).

Am I missing something. Do I have all the right bays designated for the Corvettes? My only dissatisfaction with this scheme might be the slightly pejorative connotation of the word "Basic."

1 comment:

  1. Variations gets even murkier when you take into account the late changes to 1e (UA & survival guides), 2e (Player's Option series), and 4e (Essentials). Also muddying the waters are the very late Basic sets: "The New Easy-to-Master Dungeons & Dragons Game" and "The Classic Dungeons & Dragons Game". That's what, 16 different rule sets or flavors of D&D? Seventeen if you peel the RC from BECMI.


Comments are moderated; please be patient.